These views were supplemented by a piece in
the Washington Post by Abigail Trafford, the editor of that newspaper's
weekly health supplement, who was herself a victim of Graves' disease. Ms.
Trafford warned her readers of "the bad news: It is difficult to live with
and adjust to Graves's disease. What's missing in all the upbeat press
releases from the White House is the powerful emotional impact the disease
has on many patients and the effects of hyperthyroidism on mood, behavior,
and judgment. And while Graves' is, indeed, curable, it can take months,
sometimes years, for people to get their thyroid function back to normal."
Joshua L. Cohen, assistant professor of medicine at George Washington
University, told Ms. Trafford that "Graves' disease strikes on a
psychological basis and it strikes a population that is not used to the
concept of being sick." According to Washington endocrinologist James N.
Ramey, "There's no question that the emotions are severely out of whack."
Terry Taylor, acting chief of endocrinology at Georgetown University
Medical Center described Graves' patients: "Emotionally, they can be
feeling very good and then very bad. There are a lot of ups and
downs....They cry at TV ads." "It takes several half-lives to get the
thyroid level in the blood down." Therefore some patients take three
months to feel like "their old selves," and some take a year. Ms. Trafford
recalls that on August 10, 1990, during the first week, of the Gulf
crisis, when Bush left for his summer vacation in Maine, he was heard to
say:
Life goes on. Gotta keep moving. Can't
stay in one place all the time. [fn 40]
According to the Textbook of
Medical-Surgical Nursing by Lillian Sholtis Brunner and Doris Smith
Suddarth, hyperthyroidism "may appear after an emotional shock, nervous
strain, or an infection -- but the exact significance of these
relationships is not understood." According to these authors, "patients
with well-developed hyperthyroidism exhibit a characteristic group of
symptoms and signs. Their presenting symptom is often nervousness. They
are emotionally hyperexcitable; their state of mind is apt to be irritable
and apprehensive; they cannot sit quietly; they suffer from palpitation;
and their pulse is abnormally rapid at rest as well as on exertion." The
disease "may progress relentlessly, the untreated patient becoming
emaciated, intensely nervous, delirious -- even disoriented -- and the
heart eventually 'racing itself to death.'" These authors also point out
that "no treatment for hyperthyroidism has been discovered that combats
its basic cause," even though a number of forms of treatment are
available. Within the context of treatment, the following "overview of
nursing management" is recommended:
The objectives of nursing care are to
assist the patient in overcoming his symptoms and to help him return to a
euthyroid condition. The nurse maintains a calm manner and understands
that much of his nervousness and anxiety is beyond his control. Activities
to lessen the irritability of the nervous system may include the
following: protecting the patient from stressful experiences, such as
upsetting visitors or the presence of annoying or very ill patients;
providing a cool and uncluttered environment; and encouraging the patient
to enjoy pleasant music, light television entertainment, and interesting
and relaxing hobbies. [fn 41]
This is hardly a description of the White
House situation room.
During the course of this debate,
newspapers printed summaries of substances which are thought to have an
influence on thyroid activity. These included germs such as yersinia
enterocolitica, certain types of retrovirus, lithium, iodine, and the
so-called goitrogens. This last category includes chemicals found in
vegetables such as broccoli and cabbage.
The New York Times of May 19 carried two
letters to the editor on this subject. One, from Professor Franklin M.
Loew, Dean of the Tufts University Veterinary School, recalled that
vegetables of the brassica family, such as brussel sprouts, kale, and
broccoli contain substances that may help to prevent Graves' disease. The
other letter reported that the popular guide, Prescription for Nutritional
Healing, recommends plenty of broccoli to guard against the dangers of the
overactive thyroid. All of this once again posed the question of Bush's
outbursts about broccoli, which may have been urged on his by physicians
seeking a way to mitigate some of his symptoms.
On May 29, Bush's foremost political
prisoner, Lyndon H. LaRouche commented on Bush's mental health:
....In the past several days,
particularly, there has been increasing discussion of President George
Bush's state of mental health. At the same time, questions have been
raised as to which of his decisions, beginning for example with the Panama
decisions and the Iraqi decisions, might have been caused, or largely
shaped, by the influence of a mental disorder. ...I base myself primarily
upon what I have directly observed and have also reported since my
observation of a press conference which President Bush delivered during
the high point of the US invasion of Panama, at the end of 1989. At that
time, I observed, from what I saw on the television screen, that the
President was in a dissociated state such that at least at that moment or
in that context, the stresses of what he was doing had overwhelmed him,
and he was to all intents and purposes virtually psychotic at that time."
LaRouche illustrated Bush's disorder with
the following example:
Many of us know, sometime,
quasi-successful or successful business executives and others who are most
unpleasant personalities to work with, precisely because they are given to
obsessions, and can be set off into terrible states of rage if any of
these irrational obsessions is disturbed. That is, if these obsessions are
frustrated in any way, the obsession may erupt as a glower at work, on the
job or elsewhere; it may take the form of the launching of a vendetta
against some person on the slightest kinds of flimsy pretext; it may also
take the form of kicking the wife, the children, the family dog on the
weekend, at home, to compensate for the frustration that is experienced in
the week before. We're all familiar with this type of personality; no one
can go through life without knowing a number of close contacts whom one
has closely observed who have a problem in this direction. We also know of
cases, when extremely stressed, overloaded --shall we say, circuits
overloaded -- that the behavior we see is that which we would rightly
associate with a psychotic or semi-psychotic state, as I observed in
George Bush first in that press conference broadcast in the high point of
the US invasion of Panama.
There is no question, on the one hand,
that if George Bush is such a personality -- and there is no doubt that he
is a disturbed personality who has great difficulty in coping rationally
with the frustrations associated with his office under present conditions
-- there's no question that what he did in Panama, what he did in Iraq at
some points must have been colored by psychosis, or this kind of
psychosis. [fn 42]
Was Operation Desert Storm really
Operation Thyroid Storm? On May 20, one of the most fanatical supporters
of war against Iraq had attempted to pre-empt the discussion of the role
of hyperthyroid mental instability in Bush's military decisions. This was
William Safire, who wrote:
Next, with more sinister intent, we can
expect this question: To what extent was the President's
uncharacteristically activist mindset after the Iraqi invasion affected by
a hyperthyroid condition? Was he hyper last August 2? Did the overactive
gland affect his decision to launch the air war or the ground war early
this year? [fn 43]
Bush himself had been asked to comment
about this possibility. He replied that any idea that his warmongering in
the Gulf had been facilitated by his thyroid disorder was "just plain,
old- fashioned malarkey." Before leaving on a visit to St. Paul,
Minnesota, Bush protested that his health was fine. "I'm not wary, you
know, wondering what happens next," he said. It makes me happy
everything's okay. They diagnosed it right, treated it right, and there's
nothing more serious to it." Just after he had boarded Air Force One at
Andrews Air Force Base for his trip to the Twin Cities, Bush called
reporters together and declared: "I just want to say everything's fine."
Asked about any side effects of the five medicines he was then taking,
Bush answered that his medication "affects my tummy. But it doesn't affect
my willingness and eagerness to get to the office." In an apparent
allusion to Lincoln's celebrated comment on the alleged alcoholism of Gen.
Grant, Bush even suggested that his thyroid excess may have been an
advantage: "There's a great man who suggested, 'If that's your problem,
then get more thyroid problems because it went very well, indeed.'" [fn
44]
During June, there were hints from Bush
and his retinue that he might not run for president again in 1992. This
was largely a cynical public relations ploy, attempting to generate a
story when it was clear that Bush was monomaniacally obsessed with holding
onto power as long his he could and by any means. On a visit to Los
Angeles, Bush alluded to this question, and tried to portray himself as a
man whose sense of duty to the voters would only allow him to consider
re-election if he were in perfect condition. Would he run again? "I
haven't decided. It's too early. Don't push me." There was the testy note
again. Any reasons why he might not? "Can't really think of a reason
except, certainly, health."
I'd owe it to the American people to say,
'Hey, I'm up for the job for four more years.' I think [my] health's in
good enough shape to certify, but I want to take a look at it later on. I
can't tell you I feel perfect yet, but I'm getting there....I want to get
off all this medicine. [fn 45]
I'm absolutely convinced on that one --
if you had to ask me on that one today -- I think health's in good enough
shape to certify, 'Yeah.' But I want to take a look at it later on. I
don't know. I've got a strong-willed wife. Oh, she's strong. The Silver
Fox, boy.
It wouldn't be decided running from a
battle. The fact if there's a battle, and there will be, that would make
me inclined to say I'm going to be a candidate. [fn 46]
As part of this same deception number,
Barbara Bush also floated a trial balloon that George might renounce the
second half of his birthright. Speaking of the period 1993-1997, Mrs. Bush
told a reporter, "I wouldn't mind if he gave [those years] to me. I
wouldn't mind if he didn't, I would not be terribly disappointed if he
didn't run." In the course of this interview, Mrs. Bush also revealed that
George, despite his hyperthyroid treatment, was still manic enough to want
to play golf at the crack of dawn: "Sometimes he says to me at 5 in the
morning, "If you played golf we could go out and play right now.'" Mrs.
Bush admitted that she was now taking golf lessons; "I want to be with
George," she explained. [fn 47]
But six weeks later, during the course of
the Moscow summit, Mrs. Bush rose above her personal concerns to look
historical necessity straight in the eye: "I really think he has to run
again, honestly." And why was that? "For the country's sake. I think he's
got a lot left to do, and I think he has to. Now, I don't want that to be
a public announcement." How about lingering doubts on Bush's physical
condition? "He is well. And you know myths get started, and we've got to
stop it. The president is very well. He jogged on Sunday and played 18
holes of golf. Plus we had a large group for dinner. The president is
great." Repeating this line for ABC and NBC television, Mrs. Bush denied
that she would try to talk George out of a bid for a second term. She
suggested that such ideas were largely the creation of the press, a
slightly disingenuous posture. [fn 48]
As for the burning issue of Dan Quayle's
precious bodily fluids, the tests ordered in May revealed that there was
some lead in the old pipes at the Naval Observatory. Marilyn Quayle shared
this vital intelligence with a group of Republican fat cats at a
fundraiser in Orlando, Florida. "We've gotten some reports back that
weren't real heartening," said Marilyn. "We had higher lead [levels] than
what was supposed to be there in some of the different spigots, but it
wasn't all over the house. We want to have it redone because it didn't
make any sense." But experts maintained that there is no connection
between lead and Graves' disease. [fn 49] Of course, lead-lined goblets
and other drinking vessels used by the wealthy during the Roman Empire
have sometimes been cited as a factor in the notable mental instability of
many emperors.
In early August, Bush met with a group of
perception pimps and other political advisers at his Camp David retreat.
Pollster Bob Teeter was there, along with Robert Mosbacher, who was on the
inside track to chair the campaign. Also present were Brady, Quayle,
Sununu, William Kristol of Quayle's staff, and media expert Roger Ailes. A
few days earlier, Bush had stated that "only a health problem" might make
him drop out, but "I don't have one right now. On the same day, Burton Lee
had certified Bush as being "in excellent health." [fn 50] By late
October, the Bushmen were already holding $1000-a-plate fundraising
dinners, complete with Bush, Quayle, Mosbacher, and other heavies of the
regime. Bush was running, with a vengeance.
Comparing the evidence adduced here so
far about the etiology and symptoms of Basedow's disease with Bush's
pattern of activity in 1988-1991, three general conclusions are suggested:
1. Since 1987-88 at the latest, George
Bush has exhibited a marked tendency towards obsessive rage states, often
expressed by compulsive public displays of extreme anger and lack of self-
control. These obsessive rage states and the quasi-psychotic impulses
behind them may be regarded as the probable psychological trigger for
Basedow's disease, a psychosomatic, autoimmune disorder.
2. There is much evidence that important
decisions, including most notably Bush's decisions militarily to attack
Panama and Iraq, were substantially facilitated by these obsessive rage
states.
3. There are indications that Bush's
inability to kill or capture Saddam Hussein, combined with his inability
to destroy the Baath party government of Iraq, frustrated of one of Bush's
obsessive compulsions and may thus have contributed to a hyperthyroid
crisis and the emergence of atrial fibrillation in early May of 1991.
Alternatively, the accumulated tensions of the Gulf crisis, possibly in
some combination with other events, may have been sufficient to
precipitate Bush's hospitalization.
The question that remains to be
considered is whether Bush can be considered cured of the mental and
physiological disorders involved with his hyperthyroid crisis. The answer
is that Bush demonstrably continues to exhibit those symptoms of rage,
irritability, uncontrollable outbursts, compulsive and frenetic activity,
and impulsive decisions which we must conclude were part of the trigger
for Basedow's disease in the first place. During the first six months
after Bush drank his cocktail of radioactive iodine, and he did not become
any more tranquil. His agenda has remained packed, and his sports calendar
frenetic. He still tends to make unpredictable snap decisions. He had
often lost control of his emotions in public, most often through rage, but
also through weeping and other forms of affective upheaval.
June 5: Bush addressed the annual meeting
of the Southern Baptist Convention in Atlanta, Georgia, and recounted his
tearful Camp David decision to launch war in the Gulf. "And the tears
started to roll down the cheeks, and our minister smiled back, and I no
longer worried how it looked to others," Bush told the Baptists. As viewed
by Andrew Rosenthal of the New York Times, the scene proceeded as follows:
At that moment, Mr. Bush's voice broke,
and tears filled his eyes. He brushed at them with a finger. Then he
turned to one of the cameras near the lectern, flashed one of the
incongruous grins that often appear in his moments of emotional
discomfort, and pointed to his cheek. "Here we go," he said.
Mr. Bush confessed to reporters afterward
that he felt a little embarrassed by his display of emotion before the
delegates. "I do that in church," he said. "Maybe in public it's a kind of
a first, or maybe a third." [fn 51]
According to other accounts, Bush's
"voice cracked," and he "grew husky and choked."
June 16: Bush visited Los Angeles to
attend a party thrown by Malibu producer Jerry Weintraub, who has been
responsible for such films as "The Karate Kid" and "My Stepmother is an
Alien." Bush also played golf with Ronald Reagan, outdriving and
outputting the aging former president. One press account suggests that
Bush maintained his hyperthyroid pace:
Apart from playing golf, Mr. Bush
continued his usual mad dash of recreation. This morning, he was in such a
hurry to get to a tennis game that his motorcade roared off without his
personal aide, his personal physician, and, more important, the military
officer who carries codes for launching nuclear missiles. Unnerved by this
omission, White House aides hurriedly rounded up transportation and sped
the officer to the tennis courts.
During this trip, Bush also experienced a
rage outburst set off by a reporter's reference to the 1988 Newsweek cover
that explored "the wimp factor." This set Bush off as follows:
You're talking to the wimp. You're
talking to the guy that had a cover of a national magazine that I'll never
forgive, put that label on me. [fn 52]
July 11-12: On July 11, Bush received a
visit from Japanese Prime Minister Toshiki Kaifu at Kennebunkport. He was
asked about senate hearings on his nomination of Robert Gates to be head
of the CIA. (With anything but a rubberstamp Congress, the Gates
nomination would have had to be seen as a gratuitous provocation. Gates
had been up to his neck in Iran-contra and the coverup thereof, and had
withdrawn during a previous attempt to occupy the same office. Now Bush
was stirring up the Iran-contra affair once again. Washington rumor had it
that Bush's first choice for the post had been Don Gregg, and that Bush's
handlers had exhausted their energies in persuading Bush to renounce this
even bigger provocation. When Bush had been forced to drop Gregg, he had
insisted on Gates. Obsessions and hyperthyroidism had been at work in all
this. Now Bush was asked about Gates: was his story credible that he knew
nothing of illegal funds transfer when those above and below him in the
chain of command knew all about it? Bush's first comment was moderate in
tone:
Doesn't stretch my credibility because I
believe firmly in Bob Gates's word. And he's a man of total honor, and he
should be confirmed as Director of Central Intelligence. And when you have
behind-doors, closed-door allegations that nobody really knows anything
about, I'm not sure where the fairness element comes in on that one, Jim.
The next day, July 12, Bush engaged in a
question and answer session with reporters. Bush was dressed in sporting
togs, but today he was out of control. His first impulse was to escape
from the reporters:
Hey, listen. I've got to go now. Heavy
recreation coming up before we go abroad, so I've got to keep going.
He fought off some questions about
Clarence Thomas allegedly smoking marijuana, commenting that this was not
disqualifying. Then, there was a mention of Gates:
Q: Has Gates told you about-
That touched Bush's obsession of the day.
Gates had been accused of complicity in Iran-contra gun-running and drug
running; but Bush himself had once again come under attack for his role in
the October surprise conspiracy to delay the release of US hostages held
in Teheran. Several days before, the former director of Central American
affairs for the CIA, Alan Fiers, had admitted lying to Congress. Special
prosecutor Lawrence Walsh was continuing his investigation, and it was now
clear that the Senate would not vote on the Gates nomination until the
autumn. At this point Bush broke in, and with a contorted face launched
into an interminable enraged monologue, angrily brushing aside
interruptions. The passages are worth reproducing here in detail because
of the insight they afford into the workings of a tormented mind:
Bush: Let me say something on the Gates
matter. What are we coming to here? You're talking to somebody who had to
prove his innocence --me--on the basis of rumor. It was alleged by people
that we weren't sure who they were, that I was in Paris at some deal to
keep Americans in captivity. That's what the allegation was against me.
And I'm saying to myself, who's making these allegations? What's the
evidence? What have we come to where a man has to prove his innocence
against some fluid, movable charge?
And now I'm thinking about Bob Gates. And
I'm saying: What is this all about? Isn't the people that might be
accusing him of something --shouldn't it be their responsibility under the
American system of fairplay? I have full confidence in him. But what is
this system where we hear some leak in some newspaper that behind closed
doors somebody has said something, and thus a lot of people run for cover?
I have confidence in Gates. And if
somebody wants to accuse him of something, the Senate is absolutely right
in getting that determination made and asking for the evidence, but they
ought not to have it obscured by some testimony that's been going on for
four years. They ought not to accept a rumor. They ought not to panic and
run like a covey of quail because somebody has made an allegation against
a man whose work I trust and who, as I understand it, hasn't been fingered
by what's coming out of this process.
And so, I'm glad this has come up again
because I think what we're entitled to in this country is fairplay,
innocence until guilty. And yes, the Senate has an obligation, but let's
call these witnesses that are supposed to know something bad. Isn't Bob
Gates entitled to that? I mean, why let them run for cover and say let's
hang it out all over next summer? Now, if Gates wants to do that, that's
fine. But if somebody asked me about it, I'd say, hey, get the men up
there that are making these --
Q: We don't understand--
Bush: Excuse me -- get the men up there
that are making these allegations. Isn't that the American system of
justice? What is it when we hear something leaked to a newspaper and we
all run for cover because we're -- not me, because I know Bob Gates and I
have total confidence in the man's integrity and honor. And if the Senate
wants -- and the Senate, I think, now owes it to him to promptly call his
accusers or those who they think -- who we understand from newspaper
articles are supposedly making accusations against him. And don't let them
stay under cover, "well, we can't do that because we have this other
ongoing testimony" or some behind- closed-doors, what do they call these
--indictment proceedings going on. That's not the American way.
We sent this nomination up some time ago.
And if everybody's going to get flustered and panic because of some
allegation by some -- where we don't even know that the person is accusing
him of anything -- all I'm saying is fairplay. The American --
Q: Do you think--
Bush: May I finish? The American people
understand fairplay. And I just hope the Senate will keep this in mind. I
have no argument with Senator Boren, Senator Murkowski wanting to get to
the bottom of it. But this idea that it will be served by leaving it out
all summer -- you know and I know there will be questions every single day
-- what about this allegation? What about that? All I'm saying is, from
everything I've seen, yes, let's get to the bottom of it, but lets' bring
forward these people that are supposedly fingering him. Let's bring
forward and let them stand there under oath before the Senate, as I think
the Senate intends to do. But why wait? Why not -- this nomination has
been there a long time, and now we're hearing that there's some process
going on behind-closed-doors someplace by some witness who hasn't fingered
Gates, but that's enough to hold this up.
If Bob Gates wants to hold it up, fine.
If he says to me we want to delay it, fine. But other than that, let the
American system of fairplay work. Let innocence until proven guilty be the
guideline here. And let promptness-- we need a good-- a new Director to
follow on an excellent Director, and we need it soon, to run this
intelligence community.
So, that's my position. And I'm glad,
Jim, that you raised it again because I really feel strongly about this. I
just don't think it's the American way to bring a good man down by rumor
and insinuation. That's not the system.
After several more questions and answers
on Gates, there was a question on a move afoot in the House to launch the
first formal investigation of the October surprise affair, including
Bush's role. Was it a fishing expedition?
Bush: Well, I wouldn't accuse the Speaker
of that. The man --he's another one that's-- too much integrity to be in
that mode. I think he's in a difficult position. But let's see the
evidence, bring it forth. If they're still charging that I was in Paris on
October 20th, if it's that kind of case, fine. But the evidence is --what
happened-- you know, here's a good case. All this rumor, can't quite pin
it down, but as Vice President, the President -- now President - - was
supposed to have been in Paris in the month of October, specifically on
October 20th. Who's accusing me? Well, nobody's really accusing you of it,
but every paper's got it.
We come forth with evidence which
includes almost minute-by- minute certification as to where I was, and
then they say, well, maybe that's laid to rest, but somebody else is
supposed to have been someplace else. Maybe the way to lay it to rest is
through what Foley's talking about. And if he decides that, look, he'll
have full cooperation from me. How long can you keep denying your
knowledge or involvement on something that didn't happen, as far as I
know? But maybe he's got some other evidence. But it just seems a little
weird that it keeps going. You shoot down one thing, and somebody else
raises another.
Q: Are you certain that Casey had no
dealings that could be interpreted --
Bush: I have no knowledge of what Casey
can do, or did do. The man's dead. Let's have some more interviews with a
dead man. You know what I mean? Get it? (Laughter).
Q: I think so. (Laughter)
Q: Mr. President, to clear --
Bush: Hey, I've got to go fishing, it's
much more important than doing this. Yes, Helen? No.
Q: Mr. President, to clear the air and
get everything out in the open, could you order the release of the CIA
telephone conversations?
Bush: I'm leaving all this in the hands
of the legal authorities and I am not going to intervene in a court
proceeding. I am not a lawyer. I don't want to have some 22-year old
prosecutor jump up and say that the President has -- (Laughter)--
frustrated the process here. I don't know enough about that. You've got
good lawyers that do. I don't know enough about scheduling or how evidence
before grand juries work, and I'm disinclined to learn. But I do know a
little something about fairplay. And all I'm trying to say is, let's
revert to that standard. Let's use that as the guide here and not get
caught up in some niggling, legal point.
I'm seeing a man's character getting
damaged, just as I feel mine was challenged when they said, hey, prove
your innocence. You're guilty until innocent. Prove you weren't in Paris
on -- whatever the hell it was -- October 20th. And here he went to the
front yard at 10:22. He was at the so-and-so embassy at 10:27. He was so
and so. And finally, well, that one just fades into the sunset and along
comes a bunch of other allegations by unnamed people that you can't find
and can't put your -- like reaching out and touching a handful of whipped
cream, you can't get ahold of it. I don't want to --I've been through a
little bit-- but I don't want to see Bob Gates, a man of honor and
integrity, go through it anymore. That's all I'm trying to say.
Thank you. Have a neat day. [fn 53]
July 20: Bush was on a foreign trip that
included a meeting with Mitterrand in Rambouillet, near Paris, the G-7
meeting in London, and a trip to Turkey and Greece. According to press
accounts, he was examined every day by Burton Lee. As one journalist
traveling with Bush's party tells it, "Toward the end of the trip, [Bush]
looked tired. Last Saturday [July 20], he could not recall the details of
a speech he was to give in two days. 'It's a speech in the Rose Garden to
some special group,' he told a news conference. 'Don't ask me any more.'"
On Sunday, taking questions from
reporters while posing for photographs with Suleyman Demirel, leader of a
Turkish opposition party, Bush testily objected to the tone of an American
radio reporter's question. "Now, wait a minute," Bush said. You don't ask
in that tone; just ask the question." [fn 54]
July 23: At a White House meeting with
GOP leaders, even the New York Times could not ignore Bush's "apparent
irritation" on the Gates issue, a leading Bush obsession. Bush was still
furious about Gates being left to twist in the wind all summer. "I think
the man deserves to be confirmed, and I've seen nothing other than
innuendo and reports that he must have known this or something. I don't
want to get started. [Understandable, after his previous nonstop rage
monologue.] I told the cabinet yesterday how strongly I feel about this
and so I will stand by this man." [fn 56]
August 2: One day after returning to
Washington from the Moscow summit, Bush gave a news conference in the Rose
Garden that was heavily colored by obsessive rage, as can be seen from a
front-page photograph in the next day's Washington Post, which shows him
snarling and gesticulating. Bush's main theme was an attack on the
Congress, "a Congress that is frustratingly negative on everything." "I'm
getting fired up thinking about it, Bush said. He then launched into a
tirade:
We've got excellent programs, and the
only way when the other party controls the Congress is to defeat some of
their lousy ideas and then keep saying to the American people, 'Have your
congressman try the president's ideas. We need more farsighted people like
me in Congress.
So please, American people, -- let me
look over this way -- please, do not listen to the charges by frantic
Democrats who are trying to say we don't have a domestic policy when we
have a good one. Give it a chance. Let the president's programs come up,
and let's have some support for what he was elected to do.
According to Bush, the Democrats "seem to
have a concerted policy...to tear down the president." Asked about
possible Democratic presidential candidates meeting with the widow of his
family benefactor, Bush responded with muted anger, "These fellows who are
very nice, very pleasant -- all go down to Pamela Harriman's farm down
here, the bastion of democracy, and come back and tell me that we don't
have a domestic program. C'mon. Lighten up out there." After the long
diatribes, it was perhaps not surprising that someone asked Bush how he
was feeling. "Right now, I feel like a million bucks," he replied. But he
was adamant that it was time for his vacation: "I'm history...It's going
to be a vacation. I think I've earned it, like a lot of Americans, and I'm
looking forward to it. And it will not be denied." [fn 55]
August 14: Bush's rage profile was once
more on display as he called for an extension of the federal death penalty
in a Pittsburgh speech that was also full of racist overtones. Addressing
the National Convention of the Fraternal Order of Police, Bush ranted that
"the time has come to show less compassion for the architects of crime and
more compassion for its victims. Our citizens want and deserve to feel
safe." "We must remember that the first obligation of a penal system is to
punish those who break our laws....You can't turn bad people into saints."
Bush wanted courts to be able to use evidence that had been seized
illegally: "There's no reason -- none at all-- that good police officers
should be penalized and criminals freed because a judge or a lawyer
bungled a search warrant." Journalists noted that the speech and the
setting were typical of the standard campaign event of 1988, which was
often a police group endorsing Bush, courtesy of the CIA Office of
Security. The photo of Bush in the Washington Post is expressive of Bush's
anger when making the speech. [fn 57]
August 21: The Soviet putsch was a trying
time for Bush, who staked a great deal on his deal with Gorbachov. A
remarkable flare- up by Bush came in response to the opinion expressed by
Zviad Gamsakhurdia, the president of the Republic of Georgia, that
Gorbachov was part of the conspiracy behind the coup. Bush, asked for a
reaction, was incensed:
Bush: --say to him he needs to get a
little work done on the kind of statements he's making. I mean that's
ridiculous. There's a man who has been also swimming against the tide, it
seems to me, a little bit. And I don't want to go overboard on this, but
he ought to get with it and understand what's happening around the world.
Q: Are you saying that--
Bush: To suggest that President Gorbachov
would plot to put the people of the Soviet Union through this kind of
trauma and the rest of the world through it just makes absolutely no sense
at all. Now, I haven't heard him say that, so I want to hedge it. You've
told me he said it; I haven't heard it. So, I've got to be very careful I
don't react to something that may not be true. I learned that one a long
time ago.
Here we can see that Bush pulled himself
together just enough to leave himself an escape hatch after he had blown
his top.
September 11: In a photo opportunity with
Congressmen in which he was asked about his demand that the Congress
postpone a vote on loan guarantees for Israel until January, 1992, so as
to permit a Middle East peace conference to take place in the meantime,
Bush showed flareups of rage. Bush's ploy was widely thought to be part of
the preparation of an Israeli "breakaway ally" scenario, in which Israel,
defying the wishes of Washington, would wage war against Jordan,
mass-deport the Palestinians, and possibly attack other Arab states. Bush
had been accused of anti-semitism by a minority member of the Israeli
cabinet. Was he going to lose a confrontation with the formidable Zionist
lobby? This issue was Bush's obsession of the moment; his reply was testy
and full of veiled threats: "Well, I don't know what you mean by lose on
it. What I'm for is the peace process to be successful, and we're working
diligently for that. [...] And so, what I'm suggesting is a simple delay
here, in my view and in the view of all of us in the administration, is
the best way to set the proper tone for these talks to start. And I feel
very strongly about it. So, it's not a question of winning or losing in my
view. Strong-willed people look at these matters differently. My view is
that a delay is in the interest, and I'm going to fight for it. And I
think the American people will back me on it if we take the case to the
people. But what we're really trying to do is work it out without getting
into a lot of confrontation." Was a confrontation not already taking place
? Bush answered, with his rage quotient rising: "I can take quite a few
punches. We're talking about working harmoniously together in the spirit
of cooperation. And I've seen comments from abroad that I didn't
particularly appreciate. But we're the United States of America, and we
have a leadership role around the world that has to be fulfilled. And I'm
calling the shots in this question in the way that I think is best. And
I've got some selling to do with certain Members of Congress, and that's
understandable to me. So, we'll see how it comes out. But I'm not
approaching this in the spirit of confrontation if that's the question.
You haven't seen any real controversial statements coming out of here up
till now."
September 12: At a press conference, the
issue of the Israeli loan guarantee postponement was once again the
central theme. Bush was in a controlled rage state during his opening
statement, and went ballistic during the questioning. A questioner noted
that Bush sounded "very tough" on insisting on the delay. Bush:
I just sound principled. I am convinced
that this debate would be counterproductive to peace. And I owe it to the
Member of Congress to say it as forcefully as I can. I've worn out of the
telephone in there and one ear, and I'm going to move to the other ear and
keep on it. Because this is, peace is vital here, and we've worked too
hard to have that request of mine denied. And I think the American people
will support me. They know we support Israel. I've just detailed some of
what we've done. So, there should be no question about that. I am giving
the Congress -- and I did it with the leaders today, having an opportunity
here, thank you, to do it here- - to give my best judgment. And I'm up
against some powerful political forces, but I owe it to the American
people to tell them how strongly I feel about the deferral.
Q: Are those powerful political forces
ungrateful for what you've done so far on a peace process? And why doesn't
the peace argument sell with them?
Bush: I think it will sell, but it's
taken a little time. And we're up against a very strong and effective,
sometimes, groups that go up to the Hill. I heard today there was
something like a thousand lobbyists on the Hill working the other side of
the question. We've got one lonely little guy down here doing it. However,
I like this forum better too.
This last passage was suffused with
apoplectic fury. In the next question, Bush was asked if a columnist was
right in commenting on Bush's stance, "It's your obsession." Bush denied
it, but it was clear to all that he was both enraged and obsessed. [52 bis]
Later Bush and his handlers concluded
that he had overdone it, especially in his attack on the 1,000 Zionist
lobbyists, and sent a letter to the heads of several Jewish organizations
repeating his demand for the delay, but also saying that he was
"concerned" lest his September 10 comments might have "caused
apprehension" in the Jewish community; Bush reassured them that he "never
meant to be pejorative in any sense." In a news analysis published 8 days
later, a Washington Post observer found that Bush's "ardor is fueled by
his anger," and quoted an unnamed official that for Bush the issue of
Jewish settlements in the occupied territories was "a visceral thing." [fn
58]
September 18: In a demagogic photo
opportunity at the Grand Canyon, Bush again threatened to renew the
bombing of Iraq. In remarks that recalled his psychotic rages against
Saddam Hussein during the Gulf crisis, Bush raved that he was "fed up"
with Saddam. Bush said that Saddam "may be testing and probing" his
resolve, "but he knows better than to take on the United States of
America." "I think the man will see that we are very serious about this,
and he will do what he should have done in the first place: disclose and
comply."
October 11: Hoping that public attention
was fixed on the Senate testimony of Anita Hill, Bush vetoed a bill to
extend unemployment payments to more than 2 million Americans whose
jobless benefits had run out. Bush had prepared this veto with a furious
outburst against such an extension. At a $1000-a-plate Republican
fundraising dinner in New Brunswick, New Jersey, Bush had lashed out
angrily at a Congress which was "doing nothing but griping -- refusing to
consider the new ideas and sending me a bunch of garbage I will not sign.
I'll continue to veto the bad stuff until we get good bills." Bush's
argument was that the prolonged unemployment benefits were not needed
because the recession was over anyway. He stressed his responsibility not
to break the October, 1990 budget agreement, which by that time was
producing a budget deficit officially admitted to be over $1 billion per
day. Later, as the existence of the depression began to penetrate the
public consciousness, Bush had to backtrack on this tirade. [fn 61]
October 24: Attempting to focus public
anger on Congress in the wake of the Clarence Thomas hearings, Bush
attacked the lawmakers as "a privileged class of rulers." "When Congress
exempts itself from the very laws it writes for others, it strikes at its
own reputation and shatters public confidence in government," he said.
This was a transparent bid to increase police-state attacks on the
Congress by subjecting the legislative branch to the oversight of law
enforcement agencies which are part of the executive, a favorite Bush
obsession. Bush demanded a special prosecutor to investigate the leaks of
FBI information during the Thomas hearings, and said that FBI reports
would henceforth only be shown, not given to the Hill. As Bush read
through his tirade, his face twisted and tightened into a mask of rage and
hate. At one point, perhaps in response to signals from his handlers, he
paused and apologized to the audience for getting so worked up, but the
issue meant a lot to him. [fn 62]
October 30: Commenting on Bush's
surprising acceptance of a compromise civil rights bill, Evans and Novak
report that "Bush's capitulation on racial quotas has again chilled
conservative Republicans still suffering from the year-old wound of his
tax retreat." The columnists quote Democratic Rep. Vin Weber saying that
"It's a sign that their reactions in times of crisis are not good." [fn
63] For months, Bush had sought to attack this legislation as a quota
bill, and it was clear that he was preparing to use this as a way to
inject racism into his 1992 campaign. Indeed, the racism/quota issue was
widely seen as one of the few domestic wedge issues Bush could use for his
campaign: his plan was to tell the white middle class that their economic
decimation was the fault of blacks and other minorities benefiting from
affirmative action programs. Then, in the wake of the Thomas hearings, he
accepted a compromise and lost the issue. Was this an impulsive,
hyperthyroid decision?
October 31: Bush held the first official
event of his re-election campaign on Halloween; it was a $1000-a-plate
fundraiser at the Sheraton Astrodome in Houston. Bush offered an irate
defense of his tenure in the presidency. But the audience of 800 GOP fat
cats gave Bush only a tepid response. In the words of Elizabeth Ray, a
local Republican candidate for district judge, "I thought the dinner was
very subdued. Halfway into [Bush's] speech, people were still not clapping
at some of the traditional times, and I thought to myself, 'This is a very
odd crowd.'" "It wasn't a pep rally," agreed her husband, a Houston
business consultant. The heart of Bush's highly piqued performance was in
these lines:
Anyone who says we should retreat into an
isolationistic cocoon is living in the last century, when we should be
focused on the next century and the lives our children will lead. And they
should know America's destiny has always been to lead. And if I have
anything to do with it, lead we will...I'm not going to let liberal
Democratic carping keep me from leading.
When Bush said "carping," he seemed to
spit and hiss at the same time. Then, with his bile and adrenaline
building to a crescendo of rage, Bush recalled the Gulf war and how far
Schwarzkopf would have gotten if Congress had been in command. "Thank God
I didn't have to listen to these carpers telling me how to run that war,"
Bush exploded in a paroxysm of fury. The implication was also clear: to
checkmate Congress, go to war.
It was during this trip to Texas that
Bush began spouting his favorite anticyclical line, that it was a great
time to buy a house and to buy a car. Many people across America thought
that they were having enough trouble buying groceries.
Bush's outburst this time reflected the
rising tide of public awareness of the economic depression, and demands
that he change his policy. Senator Mitchell had assailed Bush with unusual
energy, noting that "President Bush's record for economic growth and job
creation is worse than for any other president since Herbert Hoover.
During Bush's presidency, our country has grown at a slower rate, with
fewer jobs created than during any other presidency in the past 60 years."
That hurt. Secretary Brady was later sent out to complain that he could
not "understand why it is a function of leadership to try and remind the
people in this country of the recession and Herbert Hoover." [fn 64] Brady
was afraid even of the word, "depression." Earlier the same day Bush had
taken part in a "virtual political brawl" in the cabinet room over the
impact of the depression on politics, with predictions of the defeat of
Bush's candidate, administrative fascist Richard Thornburgh, in the
all-important Pennsylvania senate race. Bush's response had been primarily
one of recrimination, judging from published accounts: he excoriated
Republican congressional leaders for not toeing his line in the October,
1990 budget battles. Bush told these leaders that he did not think he
could depend on Congressional Republicans voting with him if an economic
package also contained new taxes. The meeting had been tense and
acrimonious. [fn 65]
A comment in Newsweek noted that "at a
Houston fund-raising banquet last week, the president sounded downright
petulant discussing the economy, as if he'd been forced to eat broccoli
for dinner." [fn 66]
November 2: Bush's psychological
stability was further impacted by the devastation of his home at Walker's
Point, in Kennebunkport, Maine, by a severe Atlantic storm. Because he was
under fire for representing only the wealthy, he flew to Maine on a small
executive jet, the military equivalent of a Grumman Gulfstream, rather
than using Air Force One, a Boeing 747. The furniture and some walls on
the ground floor were destroyed, and there was a considerable loss of
family memorabilia. Bush found a photograph of father Prescott in a swampy
area several hundred feet from the house. "It's devastating." "I can't
believe it," said Bush. "A lot of this [was] stuff that you would call
dear, not valuable, but things we bought in China or different trips. It's
personal. You'll see 'em floating around out here." Bush also referred
mystically to the importance of rebuilding and keeping a home by the
ocean: "We'll be here. It means something to us. It's our family strength,
being this close to the ocean. We'll figure it out." Bushwatchers sensed
that Bush's mental instability could only be exacerbated by this trauma.
[fn 67] Bush once again looked ghastly on this outing, and about as old as
King Canute.
November 5: This was election day, and
exit polls in the late afternoon showed a decisive defeat of Thornburgh in
Pennsylvania, reflecting rising popular resentment of the Bush regime. The
next day, Bush was scheduled to depart for a NATO meeting and Rome and
then for a meeting with the leaders of the European Community in The
Hague. But, abruptly and in time for the evening news programs, Bush
announced that he was canceling a later 10-day trip that was scheduled to
have taken him to Japan, South Korea, Singapore, and Australia. The
rationale offered for this reversal was that Bush wanted to stay in
Washington until the end of November and work on getting his "domestic
legislative package" through Congress. This explanation was incongruous
for at least two reasons: first, the Congressional leadership clearly
hoped to adjourn and go home for Thanksgiving recess by the time that
Bush's scheduled trip to the Orient was to have begun. Secondly, Bush had
no domestic legislative package.
Some of Bush's closest associates were
dismayed by his rapid collapse under pressure. "It makes it look like the
Democrats have us on the total run," one senior administration official
told the Washington Post. "This is ridiculous. We look like we're running
around like chickens with our heads cut off," said a GOP official with
close ties to the White House. The impression was that Bush had panicked
when he became aware that the Democratic National Committee had produced a
t-shirt celebrating Bush's "Anywhere but America Tour," listing trips
completed and planned during 1991. Bush, who was watching his own support
and popularity decline inexorably in the polls, had apparently been
stampeded by the defeat of Thornburgh and wanted to propitiate public
opinion by staying home. It looked very much like a hyperthyroid decision.
This impression was magnified by the
chaotic way that Bush's cancellation became known. According to the
Washington Post "the shock of Bush's decision was intensified in
Washington and Asia by the manner of its revelation. A White House
official involved in trip planning said he heard of the postponement late
Tuesday after a high-level meeting and just minutes before learning that
NBC News had obtained the story, which was broadcast on its evening news
program. Several Asian embassies in Washington heard the news from the
press reports before receiving official word from the White House." On the
way to Rome the next day, Bush was heard to complain about what he perhaps
considered a leak: "You got the message oozed out of the White House
before we had a chance to properly notify the parties," he berated the
press on board Air Force One. "You guys are too good." [fn 68]
Sometime during October, Bush had
discussed with his handlers the possibility of canceling the Asia trip
while simultaneously proposing a set of measures allegedly designed to
improve economic conditions, and challenging the Congress to stay in town
long enough to pass this package. But Bush had been unable to assemble any
such set of measures. One GOP official complained that Bush's announcement
late on election day, 1991 was "a cancellation without a purpose. This is
nuts." [fn 69] This Asian trip, featuring a stopover in Japan, was later
re-scheduled to start on December 30 and to extend through the first week
of the New Year. It was during this trip that Bush vomited and collapsed
to the floor during a state dinner with Japanese Prime Minister Miyazawa.
November 6: On the morning after the
election, Bush had announced a 6:40 AM press conference in order to put on
a demagogic show of concern for the plight of those born on the wrong side
of the tracks before jetting off to a NATO summit in Rome. He admitted
that he was "depressed" over the defeat of Thornburgh because the latter
was such a good man. He lamely tried to explain his decision to remain in
Washington at the end of the month as based on his experience that "all
kinds of crazy things can happen with this crowd that controls the Senate
and House." But Bush had another big flip-flop to offer: although he still
denied the existence of a "recession," he was now concerned about "people
that are hurting," and for these he was willing to "go the extra mile." He
was now seeking a compromise bill to extend unemployment benefits. Within
a week, a compromise had been reached with most of the concessions coming
from Bush, on the model of the civil rights bill. Was it another
impulsive, hyperthyroid moment? [fn 70]
November 7: During his address to the
NATO summit of 16 heads of state and heads of government, Bush departed
from his prepared text and inserted the following sentence off the cuff
into his remarks:
If, my friends, your ultimate aim is to
provide independently for your own defense, the time to tell us is today.
This was in many respects the most
astounding threat ever made by an American president to the leaders of the
North Atlantic Alliance, which had always been considered, since 1949, as
the cornerstone of US foreign policy. Bush now called the Atlantic Pact
into question, apparently in a fit of rage. Press reports spoke of "clouds
of suspicion" separating Bush from France and Germany; the State
Department and the British were known to be hysterical about plans to
expand the existing Franco-German brigade into a larger unit. US officials
told one reporter that Bush had become "exasperated" by the Byzantine
tactics of Tonton Mitterrand, known in Paris as "Le Florentin" in a
misguided tribute to Machiavelli. These frictions apparently had
contributed to Bush's outburst. James Baker and other spin doctors tried
to play down the importance of this shocking episode. [fn 71]
November 8: At a press conference in
Rome, Bush turned in yet another furious tantrum. The basic issues were
that his travel obsession had been denied, and that he did not want to
brook increasing criticism. Bush "complained bitterly" that he had been
forced to abandon his prized trip to Asia owing to "some carping by people
that don't understand" his awesome responsibilities as world leader. Bush
angrily maintained that to be "driven away" from an Asia trip "by people
holding up silly T-shirts is ridiculous." As one journalist saw the scene,
"Bush, his voice rising and eyelids narrowing, talked at length about a
president's responsibilities in foreign policy and the importance of Japan
to American jobs. His passionate response contained an undercurrent of
regret that he approved the cancellation that some Republicans said this
week was precipitous and too reactive to the Democrats." Had calling off
the trip somehow interfered with Bush's plans for unleashing the next war?
Bush reverted to his favorite theme of his war leadership: "If I had had
to listen to advice" of Congressional Democrats "to do something about the
Persian Gulf, we'd have still been sitting there in the United States,
fat, dumb, and happy, with Saddam Hussein maybe in Saudi Arabia." Bush
also continued to deny the depression: "I'm not prepared to say we're in
recession." For him, an alleged growth rate of 2.4% "is not recession. It
does not fit the definition of recession." [fn 72]
November 12: Bush's countenance was once
more a mask of rage, venom, and hatred as he stumbled through another
$1000-a-plate Republican fundraising dinner in Manhattan. He appeared thin
and drawn. The take for Bush's campaign was estimated at $2.2 million, but
press reports indicated that Bush's enraged monologue "prompted little
applause or enthusiasm as the president moved from one topic to another,
rarely devoting more than a few seconds to any theme." Bush's delivery was
halting and confused, with signs of evident dissociation and a truncated
attention span. The essence of the speech was a paranoid, self-righteous
defense against critics named and unnamed. Bush labeled his tormentors as
"tawdry," "phony," and "second- guessers." He pounded the lectern as he
ranted, "I'm not going to be the javelin-catcher for the liberals in
Congress anymore." "I am not going to apologize for one minute that I
devote to advancing our economic principles abroad or working for world
peace," postured the president of two wars and counting.
November 12: Bush, speaking in New York
and fumbling for bits of demagogy on the economic situation, expressed a
vague desire to see lower interest rates for credit card holders. Many
observers say that the two sentences on this topic uttered by Bush that
day had been interpolated by chief of staff Sununu; Sununu later accused
Bush of having ad-libbed the pronouncement on his own initiative. One day
later, the Senate overwhelmingly approved a bill to cap credit card
interest rates. With this, the secondary market in credit card debt
collapsed, threatening to blow off the coverup of the bankruptcy of the
largest US banks. On Friday, November 15, the Dow Jones Industrial Average
lost 4% of its value within a few hours, the biggest collapse since
October 13, 1989. Bush, running for cover, hastily dispatched Treasury
Secretary Brady to denounce the interest cap as "wacky." It was yet
another impulsive volte-face by the erratic and unstable Bush.
November 20: With Bush scheduled to sign
a civil rights bill containing provisions which Bush had stigmatized as
quotas and sworn he would resist to the death, the White House circulated
a directive to federal agencies mandating the termination of all hiring
policies designed to favor minority groups or women. Bush had not wanted
any civil rights bill to be passed, preferring to keep the race issue in
his quiver for the 1992 election, but he had been intimidated by the
threat that Sen. Danforth and other Republicans would support a
Democrat-sponsored bill, leaving Bush painfully isolated. That had already
been an impulsive decision.
Now Bush's attempted sleight of hand,
signing a bill and simultaneously removing the hiring policies, caused a
furor. "The president would have to lose his mind to make this statement,"
said Kerry Scanlon, a lawyer for the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational
Fund. Within hours, the offending directive had been withdrawn, and blamed
exclusively on Boy Gray, the White House resident racist who had indeed
drafted the directive, but on instructions from Bush. It was yet another
example of an impulsive snap decision made by Bush under pressure.
Intriguingly, November 20 was also the day that Bush personally pronounced
the much-tabooed word: "DEPRESSION." "I don't want to emphasize just the
bad things, to talk us into a depression," he had told some television
stations owned by NBC. It was a landmark: presidents had made that word
taboo for many decades. [fn 73]
Towards the end of November, the pendulum
of Bush's unpredictability had swing back: the Asia trip was being
rescheduled for about a month later than originally planned. By now, the
media were harping on the evident "disarray" in the White House, but none
seemed to recall the thyroid episode of the springtime, nor the
psychopathological trigger for the thyroid condition.
Sometime during November, just about the
time his approval ratings were about to go below 50%, Bush apparently
received urgent advice to moderate his "mad dog" public profile in favor
of a more conciliatory and affable posture. This occurred during the same
month. 0hatever the details that led to the renovation of his image, he
now began to exhibit concern for the victims of the Bush depression who,
according to his litany, he now understood were "hurting." He began
smiling more, and hissing somewhat less. Photo opportunities began to
depict him fraternizing with the common people.
But that postponed Far East trip
continued to loom as Bush's nemesis. Because of his desire to be seen
doing something to improve the lot of the common man, Bush's handlers
repackaged this trip as a crusade to open foreign markets to US exports,
thus helping to defend American jobs. Bush accordingly took along the
widely discredited top executives of GM, Ford, and Chrysler to symbolize
his commitment to the moribund US auto industry. These figures functioned
like a Greek chorus of negative spin, pointing up Bush's misadventures and
failures. The most outspoken of the Big Three bosses was predictably
Chrysler's Lee Iacocca, of whom one reporter said that he would probably
complain if the sun came up.
Bush displayed decided mental instability
during this trip. In Canberra, Australia, he flashed a well-known obscene
gesture to a group of farmers who were protesting his "free trade" farm
policies. Bush told a luncheon cruise in Sydney harbor, "I'm a man that
knows every hand gesture you've ever seen-- and I haven't learned a new
one since I've been here." As the Washington Post reported, "Down here,
holding up the first two fingers to form a "V" with the back of the hand
toward the subject is the same as holding up the middle finger in the
United States. And that's just what Bush did from his limousine to a group
of protesters as his motorcade passed through Canberra yesterday,
apparently not knowing its significance. Or maybe he did." [fn 74] One is
reminded of Nelson Rockefeller's antics on at least one occasion.
Then came Bush's visit to Japan, crowned
by his seizure at a state dinner in the official residence of Prime
Minister Miyazawa. Bush had vomited at least once before the dinner. "I
got a preview in the receiving line. I turned to the prime minister and
said, 'Would you please excuse me,' and I rushed into the men's room
there. And I thought that had taken care of it, but back I came. It hadn't
been halted. It was just the beginning." [fn 75] According to Treasury
Secretary Brady, Bush had been urged to skip the state dinner altogether
by his personal physician, Dr. Burton Lee, but Bush had rejected this
advice out of hand, saying that his absence would "disrupt" the
proceedings. [fn 76] After the vomiting and fainting scene was over, Bush
was asked if he intended to slow down. "Nope," Bush retorted. It's just a
24-hour flu." [fn 77] The truth about Bush's collapse in Tokyo has yet to
be told; but it was clear that Bush had learned nothing, and was still
determined to impose his will on the universe. Bush's first efforts at
campaign oratory after his return from Japan indicated that rage was once
again winning the upper hand, which was not a good sign for Bush's ability
to function on the campaign trail.
In the light of the evidence reviewed
here, it is evident that Bush's marked tendency towards rage episodes,
public fits of anger, and obsessive fixations has not subsided. Indeed,
Bush's uncontrollable temper tantrums have been if anything more severe
during October and November, 1991, as his presidency began to buckle under
the strain of the economic depression Bush was unable and unwilling to
overcome. We must therefore conclude that the treatment received by Bush
for his thyroid condition during May, 1991 and the successive months has
not remedied the mental and cognitive disturbances which were at the root
of Bush's psychosomatic affliction, Basedow's disease. This means that
Bush's health, and most especially his mental health, must be considered a
decisive issue for the 1992 presidential campaign. Citizens must
accordingly set aside White House propaganda statements and carefully
consider the advisability of returning to the White House an individual
who has demonstrably experienced psychotic episodes during his tenure in
the White House, and who has presented no convincing evidence of
remission.
NOTES:
1. "Tough and Tender Talk," People
Weekly, December 17, 1990, p. 52.
2. Anton Chaitkin, Treason in America,
(New York, 1985), p. 476 ff.
3. Cited in Chaitkin, p. 478.
4. Elizabeth Drew, Portrait of an
Election, (New York, 1981), p. 106.
5. J.D. Salinger, The Catcher in the Rye,
(New York: Bantam, 1986), p. 1.
6. F. Scott Fitzgerald, This Side of
Paradise, New York: Scribners, 1960), p. 128.
7. Mary McGrory, "The Babbling Bush,"
Washington Post, September 29, 1988.
8. Mary McGrory, loc. cit.
9. Maureen Dowd, "The Language Thing,"
The New York Times Magazine, July 29, 1990.
10. Maureen Dowd, loc. cit.
11. Maureen Dowd, loc. cit.
12. David Hoffman, "Reading Bush's Lips,"
Washington Post, December 4, 1988.
13. Maureen Dowd, op. cit.
14. David Hoffman, op. cit.
15. David Hoffman, loc. cit.
16. David Hoffman, loc. cit.
17. Maureen Dowd, op. cit.
18. David Hoffman, op. cit.
19. Maureen Dowd, op. cit.
20. "Bush to News Media: Mum's Going to
Be the Word," Washington Post, February 16, 1990.
21. "Bush Tells 'Slovenly' Press to Shape
Up," Washington Post, May 13, 1990.
22. "Transitioning in Florida,"
Washington Post, November 12, 1988.
23. Gil Klein, "Bush Not Man to Sit
Still," Media General Newspapers for the Sherman, Texas Democrat,
September 7, 1989.
24. Dan Balz, "The 18-Hole Drive to Play
on Par With the President," Washington Post, Sept. 3, 1990.
25. David Hoffman, "See How He Plays,"
Washington Post, September 3, 1989.
26. "Peripatetic Bush to Break Nixon
Travel Record," Washington Post, July 27, 1991.
27. George Bush and Vic Gold, Looking
Forward (New York: Doubleday, 1987), p. 11-12.
28. "Bush Has 'Early Glaucoma' In Left
Eye, Tests Disclose," Washington Post, April 13, 1990.
29. "President Assails Silencing of
Unpopular Viewpoints," Washington Post, May 5, 1991.
30. "Bush Diagnosis: Thyroid Ailment,"
Washington Post, May 8, 1991.
31. "The Path to Diagnosis of the
President's Ailment," Washington Post, May 11, 1991.
32. Washington Post, May 10, 1991.
33. New York Times, May 29, 1991.
34. New York Times>, May 22, 1991.
35. Washington Times, May 29, 1991.
36. Mary McGrory, "China and an Imperial
President," Washington Post, May 30, 1991.
37. Washington Post, September 6, 1991.
38. "Bush Gets 'Medical Stamp of
Approval' for '92," Washington Post, September 14, 1991.
39. Lawrence K. Altman, MD, "President's
Thyroid: Questions of Mood," New York Times, May 21, 1991.
40. Abigail Trafford, "Me, Bush and
Graves' Disease," Washington Post, May 21, 1991.
41. Lillian Sholtis Brunner and Doris
Smith Suddarth, Textbook of Medical-Surgical Nursing (Philadelphia:
Lippincott, 1964), pp. 796, 798.
42. Statement issued May 29, 1991, in
What Does Candidate LaRouche Think of Bush's Mental Health (Washington:
Democrats for Economic Recovery, LaRouche in '92: 1991), p. 3.
43. William Safire, "After the Flutter,"
New York Times, May 20, 1991.
44. "President is Buoyant About Health,
Work," Washington Post, May 23, 1991.
45. "Bush Drops Hint He Won't Run in
'92," New York Post, June 17, 1991.
46. "Among Notables, Bush Plays One Tough
Room," New York Times, June 17, 1991.
47. Frank J. Murray, "First lady longs to
have her husband to herself," Washington Times, June 17, 1991.
48. "First Lady: Bush Must Run Again,"
Washington Post, August 1, 1991.
49. "Lead Found in Quayles' Water
Supply," Washington Post, June 23, 1991.
50. Washington Post, August 4, 1991.
51. Andrew Rosenthal, "Shedding Tears,
Bush Tells Baptists of Praying as Gulf War Neared," New York Times, June
7, 1991.
52. Andrew Rosenthal, "Among Notables,
Bush Plays One Tough Room," New York Times, June 17, 1991.
53. Weekly Compilation of Presidential
Documents, Vol. XXVII, No. 28 (July 15, 1991), pp. 941, 944-947.
54. "Peripatetic Bush to Break Travel
Record," Washington Post, July 27, 1991.
55. "President Sounds Themes of Likely
'92 Campaign," Washington Post, August 3, 1991. Photos of a furious Bush
are on page A1 and page A4.
56. New York Times, July 25, 1991.
57. "Bush Anti-Crime Speech Echoes 1988
Campaign," Washington Post, August 15, 1991.
58. Weekly Compilation of Presidential
Documents, September 12, 1991, pp. 1242, 1253-1254.
59. "Bush Tries to Ease Loan Crisis,"
Washington Post, September 20, 1991.
60. Washington Post, September 19, 1991.
61. "Bush Vetoes $6.4 Billion Bill to
Extend Jobless Benefits," Washington Post, October 12, 1991.
62. "Bush Launches Strike at Congress,"
Washington Post, October 25, 1991.
63. Evans and Novak, "It was a Surrender
on Quotas," October 30, 1991.
64. "Brady Favors Additional Interest
rate Reductions," Washington Post, November 8, 1991.
65. "President Hits Back at Critics,"
Washington Post, November 1, 1991.
66. "Dragging Bush Home For Broccoli,"
Newsweek, November 11, 1991.
67. "For the First Family, a Sense of
Loss," Washington Post, November 3, 1991.
68. "Deferral of Trip Raises Problems for
US Policy," Washington Post, November 7, 1991.
69. "Bush Cancels Pacific Trip,"
Washington Post, November 6, 1991.
70. Washington Post, November 7, 1991.
71. "Bush Challenges Europeans To Define
US NATO Role," Washington Post, November 8, 1991.
72. "President Defends Foreign Policy,
Attacks Congressional Democrats," Washington Post, November 9, 1991.
73. Washington Post, November 21, 1991.
74. Washington Post, January 3, 1992.
75. Washington Post, January 9, 1992.
76. Washington Post, January 11, 1992.
77. Washington Post, January 9, 1992.
Return to Table of
Contents