[Home] [Home B] [Evolve] [Viva!] [Site Map] [Site Map A] [Site Map B] [Bulletin Board] [SPA] [Child of Fortune] [Search] [ABOL]

AUTHORITARIANISM IN BUDDHISM

Buddhist Horror Flick by Charles Carreon
It's Tantra Baby, by Charles Carreon

"Lamas, in their role as ecclesiastic or political administrators, were disliked. Their position seemed dictatorial, almost totalitarian, in its fusion of blatant power with absolute ideological and spiritual control. The situation was described as 'despotic', as 'spiritual terrorism' and 'unlimited tyranny'. Landon was severe in his criticism.

'No priestly caste in the history of religion has ever fostered and preyed upon the terror and ignorance of its flock with the systematic brigandage of the lamas. It may be that, hidden away in some quiet lamasery ... Kim's lama may still be found. Once or twice in the quiet unworldly abbots ... one saw an attractive and almost impressive type of man; but the heads of the hierarchy are very different men, and by them the country is ruled with a rod of iron.'

Tibet seemed a country of slavery, severe punishments, torture, political assassinations, mutual distrust. Grenard reported: 'The lower orders, in general, display towards the magistrates and the agents of authority a crawling servility which I have never seen equaled in either Turkestan or China.'  Lamaism was believed to be both the agent for this terror and its cause. That scrupulous ethnographer Rockhill, for example, vividly described the action of some police-monks at a market gathering:

'Suddenly the crowds scattered to the right and left, the lamas running for places of hiding, with cries of Gekor lama, Gekor lama! and we saw striding towards us six or eight lamas with a black stripe painted across their foreheads and another around their right arms -- black lamas ... the people call them -- armed with heavy whips with which they belaboured anyone who came within reach. Behind them walked a stately lama in robes of finest cloth, with head clean-shaved. He had come to enforce ecclesiastical law by knocking down a Punch and Judy show and other prohibited amusements, the owners of which were whipped.'

With some understatement, Grenard mused: 'the Lhasa government is not a tender one'. Indeed, the focal point of this totalitarianism seemed to be Lhasa, and even the Potala itself. Whilst on the one hand Lhasa was the sacred city, the Rome of Asia, it was also seen as the dictatorial centre of a police state. William Carey, as usual, painted a vivid picture: 'The holy city is more than the home of metaphysical mysteries and the mummery of idol-worship; it is a secret chamber of crime; its rocks and its roads, its silken flags and its scented altars, are all stained with blood.'  -- The Myth of Shangri-La, by Peter Bishop

50 Ways to Leave Your Lama, by Charles Carreon
The Shadow of the Dalai Lama: Sexuality, Magic and Politics in Tibetan Buddhism, by Victor and Victoria Trimondi
Tibetan Two-Step, Shuffle & Slide, by Charles Carreon
A Flaming Fistful of Reactionary Wisdom, by Tara and Charles Carreon
Another View on Whether Tibetan Buddhism is Working in the West, by Tara Carreon
A Visit to Arch Stanton's Dharma Clinic, aka Dr. Death's Reformatory, by Tara Carreon
Inner Revolution -- Robert Thurman Goes Back to the Future, by Tara Carreon
Thanks From a Grateful Nation -- Awarding the Cross of Secret Achievement to the Dalai Lama, by Charles Carreon
Born in Tibet, Again -- The Exile of the Twelfth Trungpa Tulku -- How Sakyong Mipham Usurped the Trungpa Throne, by Charles Carreon
Disillusioned by Authoritarian Doctrines, by Charles Carreon
Frequently Asked Questions, by Charles Carreon
On Hell and Its Habitues, by Charles Carreon
Tantra-Induced Delusional Syndrome ("TIDS"), by Charles Carreon
The Tibetan Wall of Silence, by Charles Carreon
American-buddha.com, Devotion, Samaya, and Cutting Through to the Very Heart of the Matter, by Kelley Lynch

Table of Contents

Art and Photo Galleries:

Critiques of Buddhism:

Buddhist Books, Articles, Practices, Websites, Miscellaneous:

Return to Table of Contents